General de Brigade Deluxe: A Review of the Napoleonic Wargame Rules
General de Brigade Deluxe is a set of rules for wargaming the Napoleonic wars at brigade level. It is written by David C.R. Brown and published by Partizan Press. The rules are available in two formats: a standard hardback edition and a limited edition with a matt laminated cover and foil embossing. Both versions come with a full colour 4 page quick reference sheet.
The rules are based on the previous editions of General de Brigade, but with changes and enhancements to a number of key areas, such as command and control, formations, national traits, victory and defeat, and scenarios. The rules aim to provide a realistic and challenging simulation of Napoleonic warfare, while still being playable and enjoyable.
The rules cover the period from 1792 to 1815 and include information on the organization and tactics of the major armies, including the Ottoman Turks. The rules also provide guidelines for creating historical or fictional scenarios, as well as three sample scenarios: Marengo (1800), Austerlitz (1805), and Quatre Bras (1815).
The rules use a scale of 1 figure = 20 men, 1 gun = 2 guns, and 1 inch = 25 yards. A typical game involves two or more divisions per side, with each division consisting of several brigades. Each brigade has one or more orders that limit its actions and movement. Generals are graded according to their ability and influence the performance of their troops.
The game is played in alternate turns, each consisting of four phases: initiative, orders, movement, and combat. Initiative determines which side has the advantage in each turn. Orders are issued by generals to their brigades and can be changed during the game. Movement is based on the type and formation of the units, as well as terrain and enemy presence. Combat involves firing and melee between opposing units, using dice rolls modified by various factors.
The rules are well written and illustrated with diagrams, examples, tables, and photos of miniatures. The rules are also supported by an official website https://www.caliverbooks.com/Partizan%20Press/partizan_GDB.shtml where you can find errata, FAQs, optional rules, army lists, scenarios, and more.
General de Brigade Deluxe is a comprehensive and detailed set of rules for Napoleonic wargaming that will appeal to both beginners and veterans. It offers a balance between realism and playability, as well as historical accuracy and flexibility. If you are looking for a way to recreate the epic battles of the Napoleonic era on your tabletop, you should give General de Brigade Deluxe a try.
The rules have been praised by many players for their realism, playability, and historical accuracy. Some of the positive aspects of the rules are:
The command and control system that simulates the difficulties and uncertainties of Napoleonic warfare, as well as the impact of general's ability and personality.
The combat system that reflects the strengths and weaknesses of different troop types, formations, weapons, and national characteristics.
The victory and defeat system that takes into account the casualties, morale, and objectives of both sides, as well as the historical context and outcome of the battle.
The scenarios that provide historical background, maps, orders of battle, special rules, and victory conditions for some of the most famous battles of the Napoleonic era.
The rules have also been criticized by some players for their complexity, length, and ambiguity. Some of the negative aspects of the rules are:
The large number of tables, modifiers, exceptions, and optional rules that can slow down the game and create confusion.
The long time required to play a full game, especially with large numbers of units and players.
The lack of clarity and consistency in some of the rules, definitions, and examples.
The scarcity and expense of the rulebook, which is hard to find and often out of print.
Overall, General de Brigade Deluxe is a set of rules that appeals to those who are looking for a realistic and challenging simulation of Napoleonic warfare, as well as those who enjoy the spectacle and fun of a large-scale wargame. It is not a set of rules for those who prefer a simple and fast-paced game, or those who are not interested in the historical details and nuances of the Napoleonic era. It is a set of rules that requires a lot of preparation, patience, and dedication, but also offers a lot of satisfaction and enjoyment. aa16f39245